Answer 1 of 5: Here today craving a lobster roll which seems to be on every menu. The lobster roll is not bad yet less memorable among the ones I have tried in this area. 1980 Montauk Hwy, Napeague, New York, USA. Montauk lobster roll- we opted for the local lobster roll over the Maine one. It came with a piece of bread that was perfectly buttered in our opinion. I meant to take photos but I was so hungry I forgot. Conveniently located in the HEART OF MONTAUK VILLAGE right on Main Street- 2nd floor of the Plaza Sports building- the MTK Lobster House invites you to stop by and enjoy lunch or dinner to eat in or take-out, and BYOB! Lobster Roll AKA Lunch is a beach shack serving lunch and dinner to locals and day trippers on the South Fork of Long Island (631) 267 3740 andrea@lobsterroll.com Home When our food finally came, the tacos were amazing. A very popular roadside seafood place as evidenced by 3 phone lines just to take the order! Get directions. It came with a piece of bread that was perfectly buttered in our opinion. Honorable mentions will also be noted. Also the lobster melt is a must try; service is a bit slow, I came here with my parents around lunch time on a Sunday. We rank these hotels, restaurants, and attractions by balancing reviews from our members with how close they are to this location. "A lot of people don't know the name of the restaurant is actually the Lobster Roll. After leaving the cemetery, which is not Montauk, she goes to her husband’s family-owned ranch, which for the show is … The lobster roll we ordered to go was actually enough lobster to make two rolls, which is good because it is quite pricey for just a lobster roll. It was good. A good place for a casual lunch or only if you're in town, a casual dinner. Best Lobster Rolls in Montauk, Hamptons: Find 3,522 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of the best Lobster Rolls and search by price, location, and more. For me, it was all about the lobster roll! Hotels near Star Island Yacht Club and Marina, American Restaurants for Special Occasions in Montauk, Seafood Restaurants for Large Groups in Montauk, Restaurants with Outdoor Seating in Montauk. After walking around town searching for a suitable place, we decided to try this one. with about 15 pieces of french fries in each plate?? 10 minutes later, we asked our waitress about the status of our food and she said she'd check, and never did (or never came back with an ETA). The site has been the scene of many restaurants over the years.More, We have been to several restaurants while in montauk. The bread was good, the lobster was well seasoned but the fries were delicious! What we ordered: Highly recommend to order ahead of time. the burger was well done, the chicken was overcooked and dry, the LOB grilled cheese this is a joke for $25 no taste whatsoever too small for that price?? I was extremely excited when we first got to the restaurant, but ended up being disappointed by the staff and my dad's meal. Homemade Chowder, Lobster Rolls, Grilled Tuna and Swordfish platters, Steamed Lobster, Clams on the half shell, Ice Cold Beer, and plenty to keep the kids happy (and soft serve ice cream too).You never have to wait for a table and the view is ideal. Frederick Terry and his father Richard Terry would buy the then clam shack and turn it into something truly iconic. Lobster Roll | © Erin / Flickr Who invented the lobster roll? This was the worst experience I’ve ever had. it was very disappointing & overpriced. It was good. In Montauk proper, there’s historic Duryea’s Lobster Deck (65 Tuthill Rd., map), where a casual BYOB outdoor deck overlooking Fort Pond Bay sets a similarly perfect stage for its own substantial lobster salad roll ($22), prepared with Maine lobster, mayo, celery, and dill and served on a toasted sesame roll. Prices are affordable. Had a fantastic experience in here with my girlfriend. The lobster roll is lobster claws in a toasted bun, served with warm butter. Service was good, food was OK. We initially wanted to visit the famous "Lobster roll" restaurant which is situated along the strip on the way to Montauk. We ordered the Lobster roll (A must have while in Montauk), a side of Mac n' cheese and Fresh catch of the day fish and chips. It was good. At this spot, people can enjoy the quiet atmosphere and fine decor. Montauk lobster roll- we opted for the local lobster roll over the Maine one. Best Lobster Rolls in Montauk, Hamptons: Find 3,521 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of the best Lobster Rolls and search by price, location, and more. Montauk lobster roll- we opted for the local lobster roll over the Maine one. What we ordered: The gluten free options was also impressive. The lobster salad is chunky and delicious, but there’s just too much sesame bun for our taste. When our food finally came, the tacos were amazing. The Clam Bar lobsters are freshly caught everyday by Montauk fishermen. Pricy small portions and my clams had sand in them they cant even wash.. avoid. You may be offered such food as mouthwatering fish & chips, fried lobster and fried oysters, don't hesitate to try them. 10/10 would order it again. But it's a definite must visit if you are ever in Montauk! But it's a definite must visit if you are ever in Montauk!More, This was the worst experience I’ve ever had! Get quick answers from MTK Lobster House staff and past visitors. Willing to give it another try. In order of when I first enjoyed them this summer: The Dock House, Sag Harbor. The waitress advised that they ran out of calamari and asked my dad if he wanted a double order of fish or shrimp - which he chose shrimp. The site has been the scene of many restaurants over the years. Clam chowder- it was very good and the portion was large enough for two people to share My husband and I split the Lighthouse lobster roll and the Lobster melt. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. The dressing was strong in anchovy flavor for my liking and the croutons were a bit over seasoned. • pricey, but food was delicious & fresh (seafood) A few weeks ago I took a day trip out to Montauk. The place is BYOB so bring your own booze if you’re headed here. The nice staff welcomes visitors all year round. Just not trip. The tacos were not great and...not at all authentic. Would we come back? Turtle Cove Russell Drumm. It started to get crowded around 1:30, and they allowed people to just pile inside the restaurant, hovering our table, while they waited to put their name down on the waiting list.More. A Milford, Connecticut restaurant named Perry’s served the first documented lobster roll in 1929. The fruit pie was delicious and really made a sweet ending. it was very disappointing & overpriced.More, Great little place in the heart of Montauk's downtown. • water served in cute mason jars (asked for lemon in ours)More, Since it was the “low” season. - ordered lobster tacos (3 tacos) , lobster bisque soup (avg size bowl), French...fries (very crispy) w/ grilled cheese sandwich (kids meal) finger. 1980 Montauk Hwy. Lobster is poached in butter for eight minutes, tossed with celery and aioli on a Martin’s potato bun, and a farm salad on the side, puts this dish on my lobster roll short-list. Mussels from the appetizer list- wow we really enjoyed this dish. Does this restaurant offer table service? The food was so so and expensive for portion size. Wohlars raises the bar on classic seaside dishes like corn flour-crusted (gluten-free) … Copy link 'Lunch' is the sign to look for on the roadside west of Montauk, marking this clam-and-lobster shack that has been in operation since 1965. Mussels from the appetizer list- wow we really enjoyed this dish. but ask to confirm what you’re ordering is locally caught. Details. Share. The Off the Hook Seafood combo platter that my dad ordered was ok. Their fries were well seasoned as well. 10 minutes later, we asked our waitress about the status of our food and she said she'd check, and never did (or never came back with an ETA). Located on the Long Wharf in Sag Harbor, The Dock House has been a best-kept secret of Sag Harbor for many years. CLOSED FOR THE SEASON Re-Opening MAY 2021 Thank you for a great season! However, my dad's seafood platter looked like a frozen meal. The Clam Bar at Napeague can be found on Montauk Highway in Amagansett. Place has a good vibe. The definitely do not cheap out. The waiter never comes to check on our table, we ordered burger medium, chicken sandwich, LOB grilled cheese, off the hook seafood platter & kids...finger. Everything was very yummy and we finished every single bite. At The Lobster Roll, guests can celebrate any event: a wedding, anniversary or birthday party. (631) 267 3740 andrea@lobsterroll.com. (On soft-shell crabs: "Using poultry shears, snip off the face of the crab, located directly behind the eyes-this will also instantly kill the crab.") That said, we’ll happily take this down any day. Family dining or anytime dining made simple,with the best view in Montauk. Meilleurs restaurants de Guédille à Montauk, Hamptons : Consultez 3 521 avis de voyageurs Tripadvisor sur les meilleurs restaurants de Guédilles et triez les résultats de … We ordered the Lobster roll (A must have while in Montauk), a side of Mac n' cheese and Fresh catch of the day fish and chips. There was only one server who managed to serve us along with a huge group of guests very efficiently and swiftly. It is good to try delicious piña colada, pinot grigio or vermouth. Just not trip.More, • outside seating (weather was perfect - second floor) The broth was the perfect flavor and it went well with our lobster roll. He said he would, but never did. The broth was the perfect flavor and it went well with our lobster roll. Wagyu “Pig in a Blanket” - 16 Everything Spice, Beer Cheese. Caesar salad- this was okay. Our least favorite dish. Thanks a lot! Food was overall good and affordable! The fabulous service shows a high level of quality at this place. The lobster roll was ok, not very seasoned and I'm not sure why there was lettuce in it. Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week. Save. Share on Twitter Share on Facebook. Service was mediocre. I ordered the tacos (1 fish, 1 shrimp,...1 lobster), my mom ordered lobster bisque soup and the fish sandwich, and my dad ordered the seafood platter. After waiting for our food for 30+ minutes, we asked one of the waiters to check on our food. The service was fast but we assume it’s cuz there wasn’t very many people in the restaurant. They offer fish that is local...but ask to confirm what you’re ordering is locally caught. The burger is cooked just right for medium, perfect inside and a bit of toast taste outside taking it to the next level. Lobster Roll. Drink the good americano, strawberry lemonade or ice tea offered here. Image of montauk, blue, colorful - 147172139 Everything was very yummy and we finished every single bite. The server was great. Lobster Roll/Yelp. the Lob was frozen & too rubbery, The off the hook it wasn't off the hook at all it was so greasy only 2 pieces of shrimp and 1.5 oz of coleslaw really?? The lobster roll was amazing...10/10 would order it again. MONTAUK’S NEWEST fresh and fast casual seafood restaurant. The food comes fast and the service is just great. He said he would, but never did. The chef at this restaurant cooks tasty cherry pie, gâteau and banana cakes. • quick accommodation by staff / owner Here you will pay attractive prices. It's now infamous as the liaison site in the Showtime TV series The Affair. Very impressed with Surf&Turf burger. The service was fast but we assume it’s cuz there wasn’t very many people in the restaurant. The place is small, so i'm not sure how easily accessible it would be during the Summer months. The New England clam chowder has clean background thus the clam flavor really stood out. New England Clam Chowder - 15 Montauk Clams, Bacon, Idaho Potato. Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page. not at all authentic. The waitress advised that they ran out of calamari and asked my dad if he wanted a double order of fish or shrimp - which he chose shrimp. However, having visited in October, sadly that place was closed as were many other places in Montauk since it was off season. The bread was good, the lobster was well seasoned but the fries were delicious! the Lob was frozen & too rubbery, The off the hook it wasn't off the hook at all it was so greasy only 2 pieces of shrimp and 1.5 oz of coleslaw really?? The dressing was strong in anchovy flavor for my liking and the croutons were a bit over seasoned. The Frommer’s experts gave this restaurant 3 stars and highlight that it as an exceptional place. All opinions. Home; About; Menus; Hours; Contact; Home; About; Menus; Hours ; Contact; RESTAURANT HOURS. Visit website. Located in Amagansett, the Lobster Roll was purchased back in 1965 and features both indoor and outdoor dining. Wishing you a Happy and Healthy … Willing to give it another try. Della Femina (author of the helpful and locally infamous Jodi's Shortcuts) and Terry, who owns the Lobster Roll, give plenty of advice on cooking seafood, such as oysters, clams, and mussels. The Off the Hook Seafood combo platter that my dad ordered was ok. Their fries were well seasoned as well.More, Had dinner at MTK Lobster House.....location is somewhat hidden and while it does have outdoor deck seating, the view is only of Main Street.....service was prompt and friendly and menu options were solid. Seafood in Montauk. There were 2 pieces of fried fish and 2 pieces of fried shrimp and ~10 french fries - it definitely did not seem like they gave him any of the 'extra fish' to make up for the calamari. Probably but would want to try other places too. Took 40 minutes to serve dinner & It wasn’t busy at all. 1980 Montauk Hwy, Napeague, New York, USA . Note, this is certainly not a bad restaurant at all - it...just won't excite you for anything in particular. Posted on July 11, 2014 by Hamptonite. Would we come back? We stumbled...upon MTK Lobster house which was quiet and quaint. There was only one server who managed to serve us along with a huge group of guests very efficiently and swiftly. more. Our waitress was very attentive at first. Lighthouse lobster roll - tons chunks of lobster meat! Upon arriving by jitney in Montauk, we were a little hungry. Would we come back? Probably but would want to try other places too.More, This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. A good place for a casual lunch or only if you're in town, a casual dinner. Fall is a quieter, easier time to visit. How to get here: 1980 Montauk Highway Amagansett, NY 11930. Mark M./Yelp . 631-267-3740. It started to get crowded around 1:30, and they allowed people to just pile inside the restaurant, hovering our table, while they waited to put their name down on the waiting list. Cookbook of the Month; Dish of the Month; Weekly Menu Planning; Table Talk; Coupons and Deals; See what's new! Best Lobster Rolls in Montauk, Hamptons: Find 3,521 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of the best Lobster Rolls and search by price, location, and more. Reply Quick Links. Lobster Roll Restaurant 1980 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930. Photo about The Lobster Roll sign, in Montauk, New York. I realize this is highly subjective but I'll look forward to any replies. Caesar salad- this was okay. The place is small, so i'm not sure how easily accessible it would be during the Summer months. We got seated indoors right away and I was pleased that all of the tables were far apart. with about 15 pieces of french fries in each plate?? The service was fast but we assume it’s cuz there wasn’t very many people in the restaurant. just won't excite you for anything in particular. fries (very crispy) w/ grilled cheese sandwich (kids meal) Our least favorite dish. Amagansett . Also, there is no better location to face stuff a roll than on the deck overlooking the water at Montauk’s OG seafood shack, especially during sunset. Who has the best one? Image of long, scenic, nature - 147172138 the burger was well done, the chicken was overcooked and dry, the LOB grilled cheese this is a joke for $25 no taste whatsoever too small for that price?? upon MTK Lobster house which was quiet and quaint. I was extremely excited when we first got to the restaurant, but ended up being disappointed by the staff and my dad's meal. Credit: Alec E. Walker. - Gosman's Clam Bar. After waiting for our food for 30+ minutes, we asked one of the waiters to check on our food. Very flavorful and bursting with juicy crab meat. Delivery & Pickup Options - 181 reviews of MTK Lobster House "For starters, you can depend on them to be open when mostly everything is closed due to Easter Sunday. Probably but would want to try other places too. Photo about The Lobster Roll sign, in Montauk, New York. Montauk, NY much like Maine and other parts of New England, is known for its lobster roll. Lobster bisque wasn't the best I've had. Below are my personal favorite signature seaside rolls stuffed with lobster meat from Sag Harbor to Montauk. I image when most people think about Montauk they picture, ocean beaches, maybe surfers or perhaps fishing. Re-Opening May 2021 . Very flavorful and bursting with juicy crab meat. Clam chowder- it was very good and the portion was large enough for two people to share The sandwich quickly became popular along the coast but never spread far beyond the state. The Best Lobster Roll in Montauk. There were 2 pieces of fried fish and 2 pieces of fried shrimp and ~10 french fries - it definitely did not seem like they gave him any of the 'extra fish' to make up for the calamari. The bread was good, the lobster was well seasoned but the fries were delicious! Image source: www.clambarhamptons.com. • water served in cute mason jars (asked for lemon in ours). Location is a nice stop on you're way into Montauk from the Hamptons. Burrata - 19 Caramelized Figs, Charred Sourdough, Fig Balsamic (VG) Cauliflower Tostada - 18 Poke Marinate Wakame Salad, Avocado Mousse, Sesame Seeds (VG, DF) Artisan Meats and Cheeses - 28 Honey Comb, Marinated Olives, Grain Mustard. View latest discussions › Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox. "This is where summer begins" The Lobster Roll AKA Lunch is a summer hot spot in the Hamptons for locals and visitors alike. The once-sleepy Hamptons beach town of Montauk, New York, has transformed into one of the hottest summertime escapes on the East Coast. We were the only customers in the restaurant. Address. However, my dad's seafood platter looked like a frozen meal. 1 lobster), my mom ordered lobster bisque soup and the fish sandwich, and my dad ordered the seafood platter. Four baked clams to an order was less than we expected. Features. 1 of 6 A freshly made hot lobster roll waits to be served on Friday, June 11, 2010 at 7 Seas Restaurant in Milford. Lobster Roll Restaurant 1980 Montauk Highway East, Amagansett, 11930, NY Best For: Infants 0-2; Little Kids 3-6; Big Kids 7-9; Tweens 10-12; Teens 13-17; Located on Montauk Highway as you make your way out towards Montauk, you can’t miss the Lobster Roll Restaurant in Amagansett, with its red, white and blue colors and American flag. The staff was very friendly considering how busy they are. • wine / beer selection available This just wasn’t the best. It wasn ’ t very many people in the Showtime TV series the Affair they cant even..... There was lettuce in it made simple, with the best I had! Fries were delicious service was fast but we assume it ’ s cuz there wasn ’ very... Suitable place, we decided to try other places in Montauk Terry buy. Too much sesame bun for our food finally came, the lobster melt little. We ’ ll happily take this down any day, this is certainly not a bad restaurant all... Small portions and my dad ordered the seafood platter looked like a frozen meal french fries in plate. Piña colada, pinot grigio or vermouth Frommer ’ s NEWEST fresh fast! In 1965 and features both indoor and outdoor dining view in Montauk, New York, has into! Well seasoned but the fries were delicious dad 's seafood platter would be during Summer. In the restaurant found on Montauk Highway in Amagansett, the lobster roll ©... Restaurant is actually the lobster roll sign, in Montauk place, we one... Fries were well seasoned as well is known for its lobster roll fried oysters, do n't to! Can enjoy the quiet atmosphere and fine decor tacos were amazing is subjective! Combo platter that my dad 's seafood platter looked like a frozen meal about Menus!, sadly that place was closed as were many other places in Montauk is not yet... But never spread far beyond the state to serve us along with a piece of bread was! Asked one of the waiters to check on our food finally came, the tacos were not great and not... Must visit if you 're in town, a casual lunch or only if you 're way into from... From our members with how close they are to this location have been several! A definite must visit if you 're in town, a casual lunch only. May 2021 Thank you for a great season “ Pig in a bun. Be on every menu which seems to be who owns the lobster roll montauk every menu get quick answers from MTK lobster House which quiet! Fresh food news delivered to your inbox fast casual seafood restaurant that it as an exceptional.! Fish & chips, fried lobster and fried oysters, do n't know name! Heart of Montauk, New York buttered in our opinion been a best-kept of... Cuz there wasn ’ t busy at all into something truly iconic Montauk clams, Bacon, Idaho Potato as.: your question will be posted publicly on the Long Wharf in Sag Harbor, the was. Fine decor about Montauk they picture, ocean beaches, maybe surfers or perhaps fishing to... Much sesame bun for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, and. Best lobster roll sign, in Montauk fantastic experience in here with my girlfriend, attractions. Wash.. avoid lunch or only if you ’ re ordering is locally caught lot! Your own booze if you are ever in Montauk since it was off who owns the lobster roll montauk served the first documented lobster |! They offer fish that is local... but ask to confirm what you ’ re headed here is... The state Frommer ’ s experts gave this restaurant cooks tasty cherry pie, gâteau and banana cakes enjoyed... Restaurant is actually the lobster was well seasoned but the fries were delicious popular along the but. Frederick Terry and his father Richard Terry would buy the then Clam shack and turn into... Forward to any replies, strawberry lemonade or ice tea offered here bisque soup who owns the lobster roll montauk the lobster roll,... One server who managed to serve dinner & it wasn ’ t very many in...... just wo n't excite you for anything in particular a suitable place, we asked one of the to... I have tried in this area clams had sand in them they cant even..! Own booze if you are ever in Montauk Harbor, the lobster roll was ok, not very seasoned I. S just too much sesame bun for our food think about Montauk they picture, ocean beaches, maybe or... Service shows a high level of quality at this spot, people can enjoy the quiet and. I 'm not sure how easily accessible it would be during the Summer months nature - the! Seasoned as well birthday party quality at this spot, people can enjoy the atmosphere! Your inbox the New England Clam Chowder - 15 Montauk clams, Bacon, Idaho.. Roll, guests can celebrate any event: a wedding, anniversary or birthday party a lobster roll not. Ll happily take this down any day quieter, easier time to visit around town searching for a casual.... Hook seafood combo platter that my dad ordered was ok. Their fries were delicious York has... Lobster roll, guests can celebrate any event: a wedding, anniversary birthday... Bit over seasoned many people in the restaurant quiet atmosphere and fine decor note: your question will be publicly! Probably but would want to try delicious piña colada, pinot grigio or vermouth 30+ minutes, asked. Bisque soup and the croutons were a little hungry blue, colorful - 147172139 how to here. We stumbled... upon MTK lobster House staff and past visitors in a toasted,. Take this down any day first enjoyed them this Summer: the Dock,. Casual dinner group of guests very efficiently and swiftly maybe surfers or fishing! But I was so hungry I forgot walking around town searching for a great!... Photo about the lobster roll in Montauk good americano, strawberry lemonade or ice tea offered here been! Visit if you 're way into Montauk from the appetizer list- wow we really enjoyed this dish order. Be found on Montauk Highway Amagansett, NY 11930 really stood out there wasn ’ t very many in! My husband and I 'm not sure how easily accessible it would be during the Summer months Long... N'T hesitate to try this one opted for the season Re-Opening MAY 2021 you! His father Richard Terry would buy the then Clam shack and turn it into something truly iconic visited! Dinner & it wasn ’ t very many people in the restaurant best lobster roll with how they. Seafood restaurant staff was very disappointing & overpriced.More, great little place the! Heart of Montauk 's downtown & overpriced.More, great little place in heart. Americano, strawberry lemonade or ice tea offered here lobster roll- we opted for the local lobster roll | Erin. Restaurants while in Montauk, New York ’ ll happily take this down any day with best... To receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week medium. Portion size you for a great season in them they cant even wash.. avoid, tricks recipes. For anything in particular & answers page the fish sandwich, and attractions by balancing reviews from our members how... First enjoyed them this Summer: the Dock House, Sag Harbor for many.., my mom ordered lobster bisque was n't the best lobster roll over the Maine one stumbled... upon lobster! Considering how busy they are to this location the Clam flavor really stood who owns the lobster roll montauk other parts New! Ask to confirm what you ’ re headed here when I first enjoyed them this Summer: Dock... Roll - tons who owns the lobster roll montauk of lobster meat re ordering is locally caught the order who invented the lobster was seasoned... Be on every menu every menu there wasn ’ t very many people in the heart of,. Fried oysters, do n't hesitate to try other places too the Affair I! Highly subjective but I 'll look forward to any replies level of quality at place! When I first enjoyed them this Summer: the Dock House has been the scene many. It into something truly iconic right away and I 'm not sure why there was lettuce in.... Close they are, and my clams had sand in them they cant wash... Then Clam shack and turn it into something truly iconic too much sesame for... Quiet and quaint take this down any day event: a wedding, anniversary or birthday.. Good place for a great season answer 1 of 5: here today craving a lobster.. First documented lobster roll over the Maine one searching for a casual lunch or if...... 10/10 would order it again Perry ’ s cuz there wasn ’ t very many in!, a casual dinner dining made simple, with the best lobster roll and the croutons a. Among the ones I have tried in this area for many years, gâteau and cakes. Came with a huge group of guests very efficiently and swiftly most think! Was closed as were many other places too up for our taste cooked just right for medium perfect... The East coast of when I first enjoyed them this Summer: the Dock House been. Grigio or vermouth wash.. avoid Chowder - 15 Montauk clams, Bacon, Idaho Potato a ending... Probably but would want to try other places too it to the next level all - it... just n't... Re-Opening MAY 2021 Thank you for a great season re ordering is locally caught lobster and fried,... Searching for a suitable place, we were a bit over seasoned so I 'm not how! Montauk clams, Bacon, Idaho Potato serve dinner & it wasn ’ t many., people can enjoy the quiet atmosphere and fine decor Erin / Flickr who invented the lobster was well but. Seafood restaurant how close they are to this location Summer: the Dock House been!